Zionism under attack
By Jim Fletcher
Amid all the threats facing Israel, one isn’t discussed enough.
The assault on Christian Zionism has been going on a long time, and it has damaged the American and European churches. The latter of course are being converted into mosques or coffee shops.
I noticed all this in about 2010. EGM Films produced Little Town of Bethlehem. Unfortunately, the film was skewed against Israel, but purported to be even-handed. One blogger had an interesting comment:
“[Arab activist Sami] Awad claims to be firmly against demonizing Israelis. Yet throughout The Little Town of Bethlehem the demonization of Israeli soldiers was a continuing theme. In addition, this Palestinian biased film gave a pass to the radical terrorism perpetrated by the Palestinian people and their Arab neighbors since the War of Independence of 1948. Palestinian terrorism was not even alluded to in the film. I felt I was watching a propaganda film produced by Nazi propaganda expert Joseph Goebbels.”
I wrote an article on the making of this film and traveled to Oklahoma City and the corporate offices of Hobby Lobby, where EGM Films kept offices. Here is a key problem with the film:
"’Little Town of Bethlehem’ presents the personal experiences of three men: Palestinian evangelical Sami Awad of the non-profit advocacy group Holy Land Trust; Ahmad Al'Azzeh, a Muslim; and Israel Defense Forces pacifist dissident Yonatan Shapira. The three ostensibly provide the filmmakers with a Christian, Muslim and Jewish perspective, but some viewers are troubled that all three support the so-called Palestinian narrative: Israel is a brutal occupier.”
At the same time, a special effort was made to infiltrate the Calvary Chapel Association, perhaps the strongest support for Israel among American Christians. Efforts to infiltrate, by Palestinian Arab sources, had been going on in the years before founder Chuck Smith’s death. Smith and other pastors like Jack Hibbs robustly confronted these attempts.
Other agendas have done great damage, though. Pastor Ginger Gaines-Cirelli, Foundry United Methodist Church, in Washington DC, says that in seminary, she took part in a Liberation Theology class. Liberation theology emerged decades ago from South American clergy sources, emphasizing an alleged connection between biblical texts and modern issues, such as civil rights in America. And the Arab experience with the state of Israel. It is a leftwing effort to undermine Israel and Jews around the world. A big target too is Christian Zionism (the simple belief that Christians believe Jews are entitled to resettle their ancient homeland). Foundry United Methodist Church was pastored from 1992 to 2002 by J. Philip Wogaman, who “mentored” Bill Clinton through his various scandals. Wogaman also didn’t believe the early Genesis accounts are real history (this is the “genesis” of disbelief in Bible prophecy, too).
On Facebook, Eric Holmberg, a strong opponent of Christian support for Israel, posted this recently:
“N.T. WRIGHT TAKES AIM AT CHRISTIAN ZIONISM AND DISPENSATIONALISM
“Speaking recently at Park Cities Baptist Church in Dallas, Texas, renowned New Testament scholar and former Anglican bishop N.T. Wright challenged one of the most deeply entrenched assumptions of American evangelicalism: that the modern State of Israel represents the fulfillment of biblical prophecy.
“Wright called this belief ‘a totally unbiblical idea,’ describing its theological foundations as ‘simply unwarranted.’ He traced much of its popularity to nineteenth-century dispensationalism, warning that ‘the chickens are coming home to roost’ and that it is ‘a very dangerous thing to believe.’”
“But Wright didn't stop there. Addressing Romans 11:26—'And so all Israel will be saved’—he rejected the popular dispensationalist expectation of a dramatic, last-minute conversion of ethnic Israel. Asked whether Paul was speaking of the Church, composed of believing Jews and Gentiles united in Christ, Wright answered simply: ‘Yep, that's what he means.’”
Though Wright speaks authoritatively, you’ll notice he does not give in-depth reasons he believes these things. Just, “Yep, that’s what he means.” The end result is that most of his audience accept such statements blindly and will not study for themselves.
I’ve written extensively about this problem, but it isn’t addressed enough. Replacement Theology and embrace of the so-called “Palestinian narrative” results from improper understanding of Scripture.
As Israel navigates this difficult time in history, we are obligated to defend her right to Zionism.